The Body is the kind of show you finish in one night and regret finishing. If you want another dark teen mystery, with secrets, liars and at least one person who knows more than they are saying, these three are the ones to start.
Pretty Little Liars
A year after their friend Alison disappears, four girls start getting messages from someone called A who knows all of their secrets. Seven seasons of twists, some of them ridiculous. Nothing else on this list will last you as long.
Streams on Hulu
Cruel Summer
One Texas town over three summers in the 1990s. A popular girl goes missing, and a shy one seems to take over her life. Every episode shows the same day in each of the three years. The first season is a complete story, and the second starts again with new people.
Streams on Hulu
The Wilds
A plane carrying a group of teenage girls goes down near a deserted island. They think it was an accident. It was not. Be warned that it was cancelled after two seasons and ends on a cliffhanger.
Streams on Prime Video
Streaming services are for the United States, checked 13 November 2026. Titles move between services, so check before you start.
Keep track of the one you start
ReelStack is an iPhone app that remembers which episode you are on, shows which service has every show and film, and tells you the day a new episode arrives. No account. Free for your first eight titles, then $4.99 once.
More lists
3 narco shows to watch after The Fall of El Mayo, ranked
Narcos: Mexico, El Chapo, Queen of the South
3 fantasy shows like The Rings of Power, ranked
House of the Dragon, The Wheel of Time, His Dark Materials
3 missing-person true crime docs, ranked
American Nightmare, Unsolved Mysteries, Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel